Go to content

Incidental detection, imaging modalities and temporal trends of differentiated thyroid cancer in Ontario: a population-based retrospective cohort study


Background — Incidence rates of thyroid cancer in Ontario have increased more rapidly than those of any other cancer, whereas mortality rates have remained relatively stable. We evaluated the extent to which incidental detection of differentiated thyroid cancer during unrelated prediagnostic imaging procedures contributed to Ontario’s incidence rates.

Methods — We conducted a retrospective cohort study involving Ontarians who received a diagnosis of differentiated thyroid cancer from 1998 to 2017 using linked healthcare administrative databases. We classified cases as incidentally detected if a nonthyroid diagnostic imaging test (e.g., computed tomography [CT]) preceded an index event (e.g., prediagnostic fine-needle aspiration biopsy); all other cases were nonincidentally detected cases. We used Joinpoint and negative binomial regressions to characterize sex-specific rates of differentiated thyroid cancer by incidentally detected status and to quantify potential age, diagnosis period and birth cohort effects.

Results — The study included 36 531 patients with differentiated thyroid cancer, of which 78.7% were female. Incidentally detected cases increased from 7.0% to 11.0% of female patients and from 13.5% to 18.2% of male patients over the study period. Age-standardized incidence rates increased more rapidly for incidentally detected cases (4.2-fold for female and 3.7-fold for male patients) than for nonincidentally detected cases (2.6-fold for female and 3.0-fold for male patients; p < 0.001). Diagnosis period was the primary factor associated with increased incidence rates of differentiated thyroid cancer, adjusting for other factors. Within each period, incidentally detected rates increased faster than nonincidentally detected rates, adjusting for age. Our results showed that CT was the most common imaging procedure preceding incidentally detected diagnoses.

Interpretation — Incidentally detected cases represent a large and increasing component of the observed increases in differentiated thyroid cancer in Ontario over the past 20 years, and CT scans are primarily associated with these cases despite the modality having similar, increasing rates of use compared with magnetic resonance imaging (1993–2004). Recent increases in rates of differentiated thyroid cancer among males and incidentally detected cases among females in Ontario appear to be unrelated to birth cohort effects.



Norwood TA, Buajitti E, Lipscomb LL, Stukel TA, Rosella LC. CMAJ Open. 2020; 8(4):E695-705. Epub 2020 Nov 2.

View Source

Associated Sites