More than 20% of low-risk patients receive an ECG as part of annual health exam

More than one in five Ontario patients receive an electrocardiogram (ECG) during their annual health exam despite being at low risk for heart disease, according to a new study from the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES).

An ECG is a common test used to record the electrical signals of the heart; the results of an ECG can provide information about the structure and function of the heart.

“An ECG is a valuable test that can save a patient’s life if they are experiencing chest pains or are at high risk of heart disease, but there is little value when patients are at low risk of cardiovascular disease and this certainly should not be a routine test as part of an annual physical exam,” says Dr. Sacha Bhatia, a scientist at ICES, cardiologist and director at Women’s College Hospital Institute for Health System Solutions and Virtual Care (WIHV).

The study published today in JAMA Internal Medicine shows that low-risk patients who had an ECG, were five times more likely to receive another test like a stress test, echocardiogram or a cardiology consultation than those who did not have an ECG.

“Our findings show that ECGs conducted on patients as part of an annual health exam are common, and the downstream effect is an increased risk for subsequent cardiology testing and consultation cascade, even though the overall cardiac event rate in this group was very low,” adds Dr. Bhatia.

The Choosing Wisely campaign, launched in 2012, recommends against non-invasive cardiac testing in low-risk and asymptomatic patients. ECGs are in their “top five” lists of low-value tests, treatments, and procedures that physicians and patients should question.

The study of 3,629,859 adult patients who had at least one annual health exam between fiscal years 2010/2011 and 2014/2015 in Ontario found:

• ECGs ordered in low-risk patients as part of the annual health exam are common, occurring in 21 per cent of patients
• There is wide variation in physician ordering, with more than 7 per cent of family physicians ordering ECGs in more than 50 per cent of their low-risk patients
• In low-risk patients who had an ECG, they were five times more likely to receive another test (like a stress test, echocardiogram) or cardiology consultation than those who did not
• Patients that did or did not receive an ECG had a very low risk of death, hospitalizations or revascularization (<0.5 per cent) at the one year mark

“Our findings suggest that even low cost procedures like ECGs in low-risk patients, occur with significant frequency, and importantly can lead to more advanced testing that ends up costing the health system more with little potential benefit to patients,” says Dr. Bhatia.

“Electrocardiograms in low-risk patients undergoing an annual health examination,” was published today in JAMA Internal Medicine.

Author block: Bhatia RS, Bouck Z, Ivers NM, Mecredy G, Singh J, Pendrith C, Ko DT, Martin D, Wijeysundera HC, Tu JV, Wilson L, Wintemute K, Dorian P, Tepper J, Austin PC, Glazier RH, Levinson W.

The Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES) is an independent, non-profit organization that uses population-based health information to produce knowledge on a broad range of healthcare issues. Our unbiased evidence provides measures of health system performance, a clearer understanding of the shifting healthcare needs of Ontarians, and a stimulus for discussion of practical solutions to optimize scarce resources. ICES knowledge is highly regarded in Canada and abroad, and is widely used by government, hospitals, planners, and practitioners to make decisions about care delivery and to develop policy. For the latest ICES news, follow us on Twitter: @ICESOntario

For more than 100 years Women’s College Hospital (WCH) has been developing revolutionary advances in healthcare. Today, WCH is a world leader in the health of women and Canada’s leading, academic ambulatory hospital. A champion of equitable access, WCH advocates for the health of all women from diverse cultures and backgrounds and ensures their needs are reflected in the care they receive. It focuses on delivering innovative solutions that address Canada’s most pressing issues related to population health, patient experience and system costs. The WCH Institute for Health System Solutions and Virtual Care (WIHV) is developing new, scalable models of care that deliver improved outcomes for patients and sustainable solutions for the health system as a whole. For the latest on cutting edge research advancing health system solutions, follow @wchwihv on Twitter.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT:

Deborah Creatura
Media Advisor, ICES
[email protected]
(o) 416-480-4780 or (c) 647-406-5996

Jennifer Lee
Senior Health Policy Communications Specialist, WCH
[email protected]
(o) 416-323-6400 ext. 3218